A Horse Laugh Ain't an Audit: The Iceberg Beneath Vermont's Budget
By Stephanie Mack

First, a big thank-you to John Walters of The Vermont Political Observer for his recent article, “At Least She's Taking It Well.”
After months of campaigning for fiscal responsibility, I discovered that a couple of Facebook posts could attract more attention than weeks of discussing Vermont's taxes, spending, and government accountability. Walters even preserved my deleted post, complete with screenshots and commentary.
But buried among the insults was an interesting argument. Walters suggested that my proposal for a comprehensive examination of Vermont's finances would provoke a “horse laugh” from State Auditor Doug Hoffer. Apparently, the job is simply too big.
What Lies Beneath the Surface
Think of Vermont's government as an iceberg. Above the waterline are the published budgets, financial statements, agency appropriations, and individual audits. Beneath the surface are questions that deserve closer examination.
Where are government programs duplicating services?
How much goes into administrative overhead?
Which programs deliver measurable results?
And which continue receiving money simply because they've always received it?
These are questions taxpayers have every right to ask.
Between July 2013 and April 2026, Hoffer's office completed 59 performance audits. Fifty identified problems involving policies, processes, or internal controls. Twenty-eight found data or reporting deficiencies, and 24 identified legal compliance issues. Those findings should encourage broader examination, not discourage it.
That sounds less like a horse laugh and more like a work order.
Apparently, Power Tools Are Cheating
Imagine a contractor telling you he couldn't finish building your house because he'd spent 14 years working with a hammer and a handsaw. Would you abandon the project or suggest he try power tools?
Perhaps we should prohibit government employees from using modern technology altogether. No spreadsheets, no computerized accounting, and certainly no artificial intelligence. Just pencils, hammers, and handsaws. After all, if something has always been difficult, why risk making it easier?
Artificial intelligence is already being explored by public auditing institutions for examining large volumes of financial records, detecting anomalies, and identifying patterns that warrant further investigation. AI won't replace professional auditors. It empowers them to dig deeper.
That's what I've been doing. I use the technology available, verify the findings, and determine where government can operate more efficiently. The iceberg doesn't get smaller because we refuse to look beneath the surface.
And About that Pony...
During my campaign, we produced a humorous video about politicians promising everyone a free pony. The problem remains that somebody still has to pay for the hay. Now Walters has introduced a horse laugh into the conversation.
We have the free pony, and expensive hay, with a horse laughing at the suggestion that somebody ought to examine the bills. Quite an equestrian operation we've got going in Montpelier. But Vermont taxpayers aren't laughing.
Property taxes, housing, energy, and government spending remain serious concerns. I believe our legislative leadership has become far too comfortable continually asking Vermonters for more money instead of examining how existing resources are being used.
I lost an election. I haven't lost interest in the budget. Walters can laugh at my proposals all he wants, but Vermont taxpayers still deserve to know where their money is going.
A horse laugh ain't an audit. Somebody still has to pay for the hay.





Comments